Butternut?

Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

MikeinOH

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2025
Messages
11
Location
Xenia, OH USA
As I experiment with different blanks I see butternut. I like the grain pattern and the color. Before I order some blanks, does anyone have experience with the wood? Anything I should be aware of? So far, my two favorite blank species are Olive wood and Bolivian Rosewood.

Thanks in advance.
 
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
It is very much like walnut. Slightly lighter in color and a little lighter in weight. I had cut some large Butternut trees on my sawmill years ago and used some in the cabinet shop. Had some very nice 18" wide slabs of burl from those trees. Wish I still had some of that stuff today yet. I never tried turning any for pens thou.
Oh that was when I lived in Pa. not Tx.
Keith
 
It is very much like walnut. Slightly lighter in color and a little lighter in weight. I had cut some large Butternut trees on my sawmill years ago and used some in the cabinet shop. Had some very nice 18" wide slabs of burl from those trees. Wish I still had some of that stuff today yet. I never tried turning any for pens thou.
Oh that was when I lived in Pa. not Tx.
Keith
Thanks Keith. Do you recall… How tight is the grain? Will it produce a smooth surface?
 
In no particular order, some of the species/types I've seen people use or comment about

Buckeye burl, Amboyna, red mallee (it can have issues), maple burl, redwood, zebrawood, leopardwood, rosewood (esp the burl), walnut and the list goes on.

I confess a real love for red mallee but have heard that it can crack over time. I can verify this to be true with a pen I've made. It breaks my heart that it does this and I've really slowed down using it. I've had a couple other turners tell me about similar experiences so I know it's not just me or my relative humidity. Redwood is another one that is very pretty to my eye but the density does not always seem to be the same across a piece so I find I have to be very careful to not sand in a flat spot. Lots and lots of folks talk about Amboyna and I've not tried it. Probably something I need to try next.

Don't forget you can also dye or otherwise treat the outside of pens too. That's a whole different series of rabbit holes. Mark Dreyer has a video on some of the things he's done over the years on his youtube channel, Ten Minutes to Better Penturning
 
Back
Top Bottom