Also, I forgot to mention, Seamus took the photo of the coin with his smart phone in the macro mode, cropped it, and then posted it to to the IAP, all with the phone, in probably less than one minute! Pretty impressive. I need to download the Forum Runner app!
As for what to cut out, I think maybe it would look good with all the middle cut out, including the $1, and just leave the the words on the outer rim, and of course the Statue of Liberty. Just my 2 cents worth. I'm sure it would look good either way, though.