I think both look good. I like the use of highlights in the 1st photo. It makes the pearl show in the pen more than it does in the 2nd photo. Maybe reposition the lights a little on the 2nd photo to pick of more of the pearl in the blank. But that's being picky, and trying to find something.
Thank you all for your input.
It's ok to be picky. That's the best way for me to learn. I noticed that one of my problems is I don't really see a photo the way seasoned photographers do. I didn't really pay much attention to the stone until it was mentioned, but taking a second look it could well take someones attention away from the pen. The simple solution to that is to do what was recommended and get something more plain to support the pen.After reading this I took this shot of a different pen today and changed the support system. Let me know if this is moving in the right direction.
Jim,
Thank you for all your help. Right now I'm only seeing the apple, but I'm learning what to look for. You and a lot of others on this site have helped me a lot. I've been working on my website for about two weeks and I've already improved enough that I'm starting to go back and delete the original product photos and replace them with the new and improved version. I never could have come this far so quickly without people like yourself sharing your knowledge and perspective with me. Thanks again!!