Thanks guys,
I was a little concerned about her blank selection, that's not the easiest grain but she took her time and showed me up!
I am really happy they both wanted to try, they already are wanting to make the matching pens.
Tom, I was at a woodworking show where the local woodworking club had set up some scroll saws and had some pretty young kids (6-7 year olds) cutting Christmas ornaments, then painting them. They had close supervision, I was a little concerned but one of the instructors explained how a scroll saw is still a pretty safe tool, with a little help from you I'll bet your daughter could do it. It would really make her day
(Before everybody jumps all over me, I'm still not 100% sure that would be the right thing to do !!)