They seem to have the things I need (or want), and have always had excellent customer service. Very helpful folks on the phone. It's a good thing I don't live close; I would be over there all the time.
I used to shop at Woodcraft when they were just a few miles away, but that store closed and the closest one is an hour away. Rockler moved their store further away and my first visit at the new location was extremely negative, so I don't often go back.
I'm partial to Exotic Blanks (exoticblanks.com), with probably the best mix & match discounting i've seen, reasonable shipping, and Ed stays active on this forum (ed4copies) as a solid contributor.
I also use Craft Supplies, USA and like stopping there when i have to come out to Utah each year (they are in Provo, just south of you i think).