Here's the deal...
This is EXACTLY what I wanted to hear and is the reason I stated
"Constructive comments always welcome". If I can't learn from those who have trod down the same path before me, I have no business asking for their opinions, and I will never be offended by honest criticism.
Several issues are brought up and I appreciate everyone taking their time to stop and give me their thoughts.
I took another photo of the pen, straight on, lying on a flat surface instead of from an angle, lying on cushy material and I think it gives a much better idea as to the shape. I also included some measurements which will surprise you as well as show what Anthony said about photos playing tricks on you.
Although I still like the shape and will continue making it because it feels balanced and good in the hand to me, and hopefully whoever eventually end up with it. I'll keep all suggestions in mind and possibly make the lower end a little thinner to keep good symmetry. I think I’m just a little gun shy of getting too close to the brass at the lower end. I crushed my first closed end pen when I pressed the nib holder in because the wall was too thin just behind the brass.
Gary, I can’t feel much out-of-round difference where the blank meets the metal but you are right, there is some. I really don’t know what my problem is, I’ve tried several mandrels, even buying two more a few weeks ago, only to have them react the same as the rest.
I have some short tool rests on order for my larger lathe and when they arrive, I think I’ll try turning a few pens and see if the same thing happens.
Thanks for all the thoughts.
George
<br />