Thanks all!
I find ebonite provides a comfortable grip when using the pen. It feels more like rubber than plastic. I get Ebonite from Vermont Freehand. Ebonite has an intense sulfur/burning like smell, which may have contributed to the odor in the box. I also get acrylic rods from Vermont Freehand and some places in the UK.
Gosh I so want to learn how to do this. And I'll admit (with some hesitation) how intimidated I am by all of the technical conversations I read about making these pens. I don't have the tap and dies and can't seem to decipher which ones I'd need to get started.
I felt the same way but really wanted to learn how to do it. So I started by ordering
a starter kit for M14 single-start threads to learn with. Getting started in kitless is not cheap, but this kit provides a set of mandrels, taps, dies, and die holders for about the same cost as one triple-start tap/die set.
This guide (pages 60-70) used with that particular toolset is pure gold for making a basic pen step by step.
I moved on to more expensive triple start taps and dies with the IAP group buy last year and converted what I learned into different dimensions. I have upgraded tools and discovered new tools to make the process more precise. I used Barry Gross's guide for making my first pens and then altered the process as I learned more techniques and figured out ways to do things better for me. Everyone on IAP has also been an enormous help in answering questions and advising me on improving.
But, starting this way gave me the vocabulary and understanding of the process to understand the technical conversations on IAP since I had nobody locally to teach me.