Turners Warehouse Kitless Mandrel Design Frustration

Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

ruadh80

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2026
Messages
42
Location
Carmel Indiana
I have one of the Turner's Warehouse kitless mandrels and it has a serious design flaw that has me VERY frustrated today.

Instead of having a square shoulder at the end of the threaded portion, they tapered it. I'm sure it looks much nicer that way, but the problem is that when you are turning something on it, the material wants to continue to screw onto that threading. Rather than having a square shoulder to stop it, you have a tapered ramp that kindly splits your material for you. I fixed the problem by making a square brass ring to sit between the pen barrel and the tapered shoulder of the mandrel, but I forgot to put that ring on and just ruined another pen barrel. Unfortunately you don't notice until you have already spent a bunch of time turning it and you turn off the lathe and realize that the end of your barrel is splayed outward. This one was acrylic, so I could solvent weld it and fix it, so it is functional. But due to the pattern (or lack thereof) of the acrylic, you can still see a faint line where the crack had been. So I guess it will be another pen being added to my personal collection.

I really need to buy mandrels from Rick, but I haven't done it yet because you have to send him the die you use and I can't go without it at the moment.
 
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
I forgot to mention that in the meantime, I'm throwing this thing on a metal lathe and squaring up that shoulder. Luckily I volunteer for my daughter's HS robotics team and we have a meeting today, so I can go use the machine shop there.
 
I cannot say enough positive things about @rherrell and anything he makes!

I love the mandrel's that Rick has made for me. For that matter, I love ALL the tooling Rick has made for me.

I started with the brass mandrels from another source and they helped me get going, and to realize that I wanted something different, so I quickly switched.
 
I checked my Turners Mandrels and they have squared off shoulder's not tapered. I wonder if they changed the design of it or if you got one with a machining defect
 
Their photo shows square nut also. I highly doubt if there is a problem with any of the tools they sell that they would not correct right away. Chad is a true turner and uses the tools.
 
I am a relatively new pen maker who desires to learn kit-less pen making. I have read a lot about the process but really don't have the machinist background. I see you all speak of Rick Herrell and his tooling, so I downloaded his catalog. Does anyone know If I reach out to him -- is it possible to get a full set up of tooling and dyes etc for kit-less? And does anyone her know who I may reach out for a clear tutorial for making kit -less pens?
 
If there is a defect I am sure Chad will fix it. I don't use those mandrels so I am not sure. Do you chamfer the opening after drilling? If it is tapered, it may be designed for the connection to be chamfered, which is typical design.
 
I am a relatively new pen maker who desires to learn kit-less pen making. I have read a lot about the process but really don't have the machinist background. I see you all speak of Rick Herrell and his tooling, so I downloaded his catalog. Does anyone know If I reach out to him -- is it possible to get a full set up of tooling and dyes etc for kit-less? And does anyone her know who I may reach out for a clear tutorial for making kit -less pens?
Honestly, if you want a plug and play type of method I would look at Barry Gross's setup at BG Artforms. It's not triple start, but it is a good system to learn with. If you get into pen making, you will want to purchase upgraded tooling to replace his kit. It is not a cheap intro into kitless pens. He will give you a step by step guide to go with his tools that will teach you the basics that you can then apply to more advanced techniques.

If you want to go straight to triple start you would buy your taps and dies from Turner's Warehouse and send them to Rick to make your mandrels. Rick does not sell taps and dies, unless something has changed recently. You can contact him directly here @rherrell
 
I am a relatively new pen maker who desires to learn kit-less pen making. I have read a lot about the process but really don't have the machinist background. I see you all speak of Rick Herrell and his tooling, so I downloaded his catalog. Does anyone know If I reach out to him -- is it possible to get a full set up of tooling and dyes etc for kit-less? And does anyone her know who I may reach out for a clear tutorial for making kit -less pens?
Hi.

This isnt a simple question to answer because Rick sells tools and such associated with kitless pen making, but does not sell the dies and taps associated with it. Infact, in order to make you the appropriate mandrels, he actually needs you to send him your die and tap, so that he can make the mandrel fit precisely.

Kitless pen making isn't inexpensive. There is a fairly large initial setup cost, especially if you go with traditional 3start, or triple lead threads.

The tap and die alone are 350$

The very first question you need to be able to answer is, "What size do I want to go with?"
There are three main (standard) triple lead options:
M12x.8 with M9x.75 - smaller diameter pens, but tighter tolerances (likely then either bock #5 or jowo #5 nibs.)
M13x.8 with M10x1.0 - Standard and typical, most common) likely to use bock #6 or jowo #6 nib, jowo seems more popular.
M14x.8 with M10x1.0 or M11x.8 - triple lead and another 300+$. likely to use bock #6 or jowo #6 nib, jowo seems more popular.

You can also start with single lead dies, more affordable.
(M12x.75 / M13x1.0 or .75 / M14x1.0 or .75)
You still need to purchase the specific nib tap you want (bock 5 or 6 / jowo 5 or 6).
Those are in the 50$ range.

Kitless taps and dies

Next, you need specific tooling.
You are going to need a collet chuck and a full set of metric and imperial collets. Go with an Er32 collet chuck that threads onto your lathe spindle (1x8 or 1.25x8) most likely, unless you have some old or odd lathe.
I would go with the stainless steel bottle stoppers collet chuck from turners warehouse. It's about 60$, American made and high quality.
Collet chuck
It has one drawback. It does not have a through hole from the front end into the spindle pocket. It isn't hardened material, so you can thread it onto your lathe and the progressive drill through the front into the socket, you just need to go slow, use lots of lube and start with a small drill bit, .25 inch or so and then go up by 1/8 each progression until you get to .75 or so, which is the diameter of the inside of your lathe spindle nose.
Speaking of turners warehouse, they used to offer a full startup kit for your desired size. It was 800$ but got you about 90% of the stuff you needed. It has been out of stock for a while.

You are going to need a drill index. Honestly, I would pick up the Bauer set from harbor freight.

Drill index

Material selection matters for kitless pens, especially where threading is concerned.

Alumilyte or ebonite are the preferred materials. They both thread and turn easily and can be polished to a high luster or shine.
Blank Material

Good luck. It isn't cheap to get into and requires a lot of patience and determination.
 
Hi.

This isnt a simple question to answer because Rick sells tools and such associated with kitless pen making, but does not sell the dies and taps associated with it. Infact, in order to make you the appropriate mandrels, he actually needs you to send him your die and tap, so that he can make the mandrel fit precisely.

Kitless pen making isn't inexpensive. There is a fairly large initial setup cost, especially if you go with traditional 3start, or triple lead threads.

The tap and die alone are 350$

The very first question you need to be able to answer is, "What size do I want to go with?"
There are three main (standard) triple lead options:
M12x.8 with M9x.75 - smaller diameter pens, but tighter tolerances (likely then either bock #5 or jowo #5 nibs.)
M13x.8 with M10x1.0 - Standard and typical, most common) likely to use bock #6 or jowo #6 nib, jowo seems more popular.
M14x.8 with M10x1.0 or M11x.8 - triple lead and another 300+$. likely to use bock #6 or jowo #6 nib, jowo seems more popular.

You can also start with single lead dies, more affordable.
(M12x.75 / M13x1.0 or .75 / M14x1.0 or .75)
You still need to purchase the specific nib tap you want (bock 5 or 6 / jowo 5 or 6).
Those are in the 50$ range.

Kitless taps and dies

Next, you need specific tooling.
You are going to need a collet chuck and a full set of metric and imperial collets. Go with an Er32 collet chuck that threads onto your lathe spindle (1x8 or 1.25x8) most likely, unless you have some old or odd lathe.
I would go with the stainless steel bottle stoppers collet chuck from turners warehouse. It's about 60$, American made and high quality.
Collet chuck
It has one drawback. It does not have a through hole from the front end into the spindle pocket. It isn't hardened material, so you can thread it onto your lathe and the progressive drill through the front into the socket, you just need to go slow, use lots of lube and start with a small drill bit, .25 inch or so and then go up by 1/8 each progression until you get to .75 or so, which is the diameter of the inside of your lathe spindle nose.
Speaking of turners warehouse, they used to offer a full startup kit for your desired size. It was 800$ but got you about 90% of the stuff you needed. It has been out of stock for a while.

You are going to need a drill index. Honestly, I would pick up the Bauer set from harbor freight.

Drill index

Material selection matters for kitless pens, especially where threading is concerned.

Alumilyte or ebonite are the preferred materials. They both thread and turn easily and can be polished to a high luster or shine.
Blank Material

Good luck. It isn't cheap to get into and requires a lot of patience and determination.
Thank you for all this great information -- I really appreciate it
 
Honestly, if you want a plug and play type of method I would look at Barry Gross's setup at BG Artforms. It's not triple start, but it is a good system to learn with. If you get into pen making, you will want to purchase upgraded tooling to replace his kit. It is not a cheap intro into kitless pens. He will give you a step by step guide to go with his tools that will teach you the basics that you can then apply to more advanced techniques.

If you want to go straight to triple start you would buy your taps and dies from Turner's Warehouse and send them to Rick to make your mandrels. Rick does not sell taps and dies, unless something has changed recently. You can contact him directly here @rherrell
Thank you for all this information -- I will research Barry Gross
 
Back
Top Bottom