MesquiteMan
Retired Head Moderator
How are we to nkow if something new is being offered by our members who are vendors?
Jerry, that is why we have a classified section.
How are we to nkow if something new is being offered by our members who are vendors?
Jerry, that is why we have a classified section.
Scott, that doesn't make sense. First, there is no concept of "accuracy" in an opinion poll. Second, why would people do that? To end up with a forum that doesn't represent their interests? A forum that makes me happy but nobody else?
I'm human, I have opinions.
It has never been my experience here that people let me get away with something dumb just because it's what I want. On the contrary, I have proposed many things over the years that never got implemented because I got honest feedback in a situation just like this.
Scott, you chose which portion of Jeff's post to quote....you need to include all of it....nowhere in it did he state a preference as to which way he wanted it....he DID state that HOWEVER the vote went that's how the rules would be written up. Stop trying to cause problems!
Everyone else is stating their opinions as well. I don't see you ragging them about it. Just because Jeff is the site owner does not mean he's not entitled to his own opinion.
Most of us probably don't know Jeff from the next guy anyway, so why would his opinion sway us???
I strongly feel that we should have a separate forum with a title such as "Materials R&D" or some such. Then, that forum needs to be MEMBERS ONLY. This will serve 2 purposes...it will move the market research stuff to a forum so that folks that are not interested in marketing can ignore it but it will also make it a little harder for the big guys to glean ideas from us small guys here.
I stand by what I said....Jeff stated NO opinion in his post. I think perhaps YOU are the one who needs to actually go back and read the post. I also stand by my earlier post...You are TRYING to cause problems.I respect your opinion so please respect mine or put me on your ignore list. If you read Jeff's reply it would seem that he indeed state an opinion and if you read his post it's not hard to figure what his preference is.
In a nutshell: Before Exotics, I could post a pen and have people comment on it. The CATalog evolved because a few folks wanted access to the products I had located. There were a couple thousand members and no one complained about the CATalog---based on email orders.
Now there are a few who "jump all over" my posts of pens as advertising. When I answer a question, I may get PM's from those who notice I mentioned a product that we sell ---"Cleverly hid that ad, but I got it".
Actually, I answered a question---same as I would have done 3 years ago without having to walk on eggshells to do it.
I propose that I should still be able to post anything in SOYP, same as ANY other member, without comments about my advertising. (Call it verbal pollution, if you will). Whether I can attach a link to an ad is, in my mind, the only "open question". Of course, I will abide by whatever decision is made, as I have always attempted to do.
As to "market research"--I believe it falls under the domain of "education" which has ALWAYS been one of the founding principles of the IAP. The pen-making public is educating ME as to their wants and desires. By using polls, I can better determine WHAT to purchase for resale by responding to the greatest number of folks who WANT a product.
As you know Jeff, I ascribe to the philosophy that we are all supposed to be adults. Drive down the interstate and you have hundreds of advertising messages (some on government-paid signs). You have to learn which ones you want to read. Listen to the radio or television, again you need to be able to differentiate your wheat from your chaff. But your chaff may be MY wheat!!!
So it's best to allow the educational information and ask the viewer to "filter" on his own. If he can't accomplish this, we should probably keep him away from sharp tools and this site, anyhow---self-protection.:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
In a nutshell: Before Exotics, I could post a pen and have people comment on it. The CATalog evolved because a few folks wanted access to the products I had located. There were a couple thousand members and no one complained about the CATalog---based on email orders.
Now there are a few who "jump all over" my posts of pens as advertising. When I answer a question, I may get PM's from those who notice I mentioned a product that we sell ---"Cleverly hid that ad, but I got it".
Actually, I answered a question---same as I would have done 3 years ago without having to walk on eggshells to do it.
I propose that I should still be able to post anything in SOYP, same as ANY other member, without comments about my advertising. (Call it verbal pollution, if you will). Whether I can attach a link to an ad is, in my mind, the only "open question". Of course, I will abide by whatever decision is made, as I have always attempted to do.
As to "market research"--I believe it falls under the domain of "education" which has ALWAYS been one of the founding principles of the IAP. The pen-making public is educating ME as to their wants and desires. By using polls, I can better determine WHAT to purchase for resale by responding to the greatest number of folks who WANT a product.
As you know Jeff, I ascribe to the philosophy that we are all supposed to be adults. Drive down the interstate and you have hundreds of advertising messages (some on government-paid signs). You have to learn which ones you want to read. Listen to the radio or television, again you need to be able to differentiate your wheat from your chaff. But your chaff may be MY wheat!!!
So it's best to allow the educational information and ask the viewer to "filter" on his own. If he can't accomplish this, we should probably keep him away from sharp tools and this site, anyhow---self-protection.:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
I couldn't have expressed it better, so just mark me down as +1 for Ed's commentary. Well said!![]()
In a nutshell: Before Exotics, I could post a pen and have people comment on it. The CATalog evolved because a few folks wanted access to the products I had located. There were a couple thousand members and no one complained about the CATalog---based on email orders.
Now there are a few who "jump all over" my posts of pens as advertising. When I answer a question, I may get PM's from those who notice I mentioned a product that we sell ---"Cleverly hid that ad, but I got it".
Actually, I answered a question---same as I would have done 3 years ago without having to walk on eggshells to do it.
I propose that I should still be able to post anything in SOYP, same as ANY other member, without comments about my advertising. (Call it verbal pollution, if you will). Whether I can attach a link to an ad is, in my mind, the only "open question". Of course, I will abide by whatever decision is made, as I have always attempted to do.
As to "market research"--I believe it falls under the domain of "education" which has ALWAYS been one of the founding principles of the IAP. The pen-making public is educating ME as to their wants and desires. By using polls, I can better determine WHAT to purchase for resale by responding to the greatest number of folks who WANT a product.
As you know Jeff, I ascribe to the philosophy that we are all supposed to be adults. Drive down the interstate and you have hundreds of advertising messages (some on government-paid signs). You have to learn which ones you want to read. Listen to the radio or television, again you need to be able to differentiate your wheat from your chaff. But your chaff may be MY wheat!!!
So it's best to allow the educational information and ask the viewer to "filter" on his own. If he can't accomplish this, we should probably keep him away from sharp tools and this site, anyhow---self-protection.:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
In a nutshell: Before Exotics, I could post a pen and have people comment on it. The CATalog evolved because a few folks wanted access to the products I had located. There were a couple thousand members and no one complained about the CATalog---based on email orders.
Now there are a few who "jump all over" my posts of pens as advertising. When I answer a question, I may get PM's from those who notice I mentioned a product that we sell ---"Cleverly hid that ad, but I got it".
Actually, I answered a question---same as I would have done 3 years ago without having to walk on eggshells to do it.
I propose that I should still be able to post anything in SOYP, same as ANY other member, without comments about my advertising. (Call it verbal pollution, if you will). Whether I can attach a link to an ad is, in my mind, the only "open question". Of course, I will abide by whatever decision is made, as I have always attempted to do.
As to "market research"--I believe it falls under the domain of "education" which has ALWAYS been one of the founding principles of the IAP. The pen-making public is educating ME as to their wants and desires. By using polls, I can better determine WHAT to purchase for resale by responding to the greatest number of folks who WANT a product.
As you know Jeff, I ascribe to the philosophy that we are all supposed to be adults. Drive down the interstate and you have hundreds of advertising messages (some on government-paid signs). You have to learn which ones you want to read. Listen to the radio or television, again you need to be able to differentiate your wheat from your chaff. But your chaff may be MY wheat!!!
So it's best to allow the educational information and ask the viewer to "filter" on his own. If he can't accomplish this, we should probably keep him away from sharp tools and this site, anyhow---self-protection.:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
I couldn't have expressed it better, so just mark me down as +1 for Ed's commentary. Well said!![]()
I have my own thoughts as to this whole issue but in the spirit of not fueling fires or attacking any individual I choose keep them to myself. Suffice it to say I have not had any problems with any of the posts that any of the vendors have made. In fact, I am one of those people who will post a pen in SOYP and post where I got the blank, the kit, the bushings I used, the tool I used, etc. I have also given credt to the individuals who inspired me to do a certain modification or use a certain material. Why? Because I appreciate it when others do the same so I will know where to go to look for the stuff I like. I thought that was what this site was all about. Sharing information. I appreciate all the vendors informing me what they have to offer. I can make up my own mind as to whether or not I will buy. I believe that most members feel the same. Hopefully we won't be deprived of the free flow of the information we need to further our craft due to a vocal minority that has nothing better to do than to whine and make waves.
If Exotics gets special treatment, then there should be an amendment that says they get special treatment. Otherwise, they should be held to the same level of accountability as the rest of the vendors.
So yeah, I disagree with the thought that vendors shuold get free run of the site. If you want commercial space... PAY FOR IT.
The Pen Shop comes to mind for those of us with "historical memory".
The Pen Shop comes to mind for those of us with "historical memory".
Perhaps somebody could call up the owner of that site and ask him "How's that working out for ya?"
I would but I don't expect he would take my call, unless he doesn't have caller ID, in which case it would be a very short call.
My whole beef is equality. If Exotics gets special treatment, then there should be an amendment that says they get special treatment. Otherwise, they should be held to the same level of accountability as the rest of the vendors.
LOUD, must not be mistaken for CORRECT!
What Jeff and Curtis decide is all that matters to me and several thousand other members.
Jeff knows of your bitch. He's taking stock of the situation. If you don't like Jeff's rules in Jeff's house, leave and start your own forum with YOUR rules. It's that simple.
If Exotics gets special treatment, then there should be an amendment that says they get special treatment. Otherwise, they should be held to the same level of accountability as the rest of the vendors.
So yeah, I disagree with the thought that vendors shuold get free run of the site. If you want commercial space... PAY FOR IT.
Not your damned call. Jeff, and many years ago the Board, decided that this site would not sell advertising. Advertising is allowed as it benefits the members. THE DECISION IS ALREADY MADE!
Jeff knows of your bitch. He's taking stock of the situation. If you don't like Jeff's rules in Jeff's house, leave and start your own forum with YOUR rules. It's that simple.
If Exotics gets special treatment, then there should be an amendment that says they get special treatment. Otherwise, they should be held to the same level of accountability as the rest of the vendors.
So yeah, I disagree with the thought that vendors shuold get free run of the site. If you want commercial space... PAY FOR IT.
Not your damned call. Jeff, and many years ago the Board, decided that this site would not sell advertising. Advertising is allowed as it benefits the members. THE DECISION IS ALREADY MADE!
Jeff knows of your bitch. He's taking stock of the situation. If you don't like Jeff's rules in Jeff's house, leave and start your own forum with YOUR rules. It's that simple.
Now I understand why the democratic legislators in texas took off for Oklahoma a few years back.
They actually look smarter than some of the people who live there.
Roy, this does not include you however.