Mannie,
Did you make sure your beans were 100% dry? That is the only thing that causes Alumilite to be sticky that I have found. I have not done coffee beans, however. EVERYTHING that I cast in Alumilite is put in a toaster oven at 190 or so fo a few hours before casting to make sure it is dry. Since I started doing that, I have not had any issues like you mention. The only other thing it possibly could be is your colorant. If it is not Alumilite brand then you are sorta on your own with trial and error. Of course if you put too much you will certainly have a problem. It does not sound like you did, though, so I was strongly suspect the later.
Go ahead and put the block in a toaster oven for 2 or 3 hours and the sticky should go away.