In my opinion, the case appearance of the posting Gent Jr's is lessened by the black threads. It would be far more attractive if the threads were the same finish appearance as the center band and the clip assembly.
As for the feel, I like the feel of the rollerball version without the cap posted. Posted it feels off balance. However, if you take the fountain pen and replace the cartridge with a pump, when full of ink, the posted cap balances well in my hand.
In terms of selling what I don't like, I'm reminded of a retail buyer I once knew who told me "I have to stock for the 80% of the public that have reasonable taste along with the 20% of the buying public who have bad taste." [
] Makes me laugh just remembering it. [8D]