Which saw for pen turning

Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

Kiwiturner

Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
18
I need to get a new saw , having sold my big cabinet saw. ( It wasnt doing anything but take up too much room)

Initially I thought I wouldn't need a table saw for pens and wood turning in general. However of late folks have been giving various lumps of wood to take home and use. A lot of this wood is straight from the woodpile and when turned is really quite lovely, both to turn and in coloration,texture etc.

So here's the question for you all ... Which style of saw do you prefer. Bear in mind at present I can only afford I saw.
At this point in time I'm thinking that a band saw would be of more value than a new portable saw table.

What do you consider is the most useful tool for the hobbyist diyer?
Budget is $350 NZD which is about $220.00 USD.
 
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

KBs Pensnmore

Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2010
Messages
834
Location
Murray Bridge 5253 Australia
G'Day Kiwi, welcome to a top forum. You are right in getting a band saw, I have both and the bandsaw is my go to, except for cutting sheet.
I have several jigs, that keep the fingers well clear of the blade for cutting and roughing blanks for turning pens and other stuff.
Get the saw with the deepest cut, as I found no matter what size you've go it's always just to small. A chainsaw wouldn't go astray either.
Kryn
 
Last edited:

Kragax

Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2015
Messages
280
Location
western new york
For blanks I use a chop saw with a fairly fine blade. It cuts them square ans doesn't take up a lot of room. I have acrylic blanks I haven't tried yet but probably have to use my bandsaw for them.
 

oneleggimp

Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2014
Messages
854
Location
Grosse Pointe Park, Michigan 48230 United States o
I need to get a new saw , having sold my big cabinet saw. ( It wasnt doing anything but take up too much room)

Initially I thought I wouldn't need a table saw for pens and wood turning in general. However of late folks have been giving various lumps of wood to take home and use. A lot of this wood is straight from the woodpile and when turned is really quite lovely, both to turn and in coloration,texture etc.

So here's the question for you all ... Which style of saw do you prefer. Bear in mind at present I can only afford I saw.
At this point in time I'm thinking that a band saw would be of more value than a new portable saw table.

What do you consider is the most useful tool for the hobbyist diyer?
Budget is $350 NZD which is about $220.00 USD.
I personally would opt for the Band Saw. For many years, I didn't even have a table saw - just a 12" Band Saw. Properly set-up and with good blades, I like a band saw for most woodworking.
 

Skie_M

Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2015
Messages
2,737
Location
Lawton, Ok
No matter what kind of saw you end up getting, make sure you get a decent quality set of blades for it and a fence that locks in place accurately.


It may also be worth your while to check local listings for used tools ... you may be able to afford more than one, in this way, but you may have to do a little extra work to fit them in your shop and properly outfit them with the accessories you will want to use and the things that they need.

For any saw, a fence for the work to ride against is generally a must .... if it's adjustable, it needs to be accurate from both sides of the saw blade, to prevent binding and burning of the wood.

If you are not using a fence, then you should be using the miter slot(s). You can create a jig that your work can ride on/in that secures it in position for certain repeatable cuts. These jigs are referred to by several different names, one of the most common being a "sled". These are made to have (usually) 2 runners that fit into the miter slots with no wiggle room or play, and will run the length of the table without binding. They have a base board that connects the left runner to the right runner (or rides against the fence, if there's only 1 runner), that carries the work piece, and a backstop that the work piece is clamped to. There may be adjustable or permanent stop blocks in place, depending on the type of work being demanded of the jig.

These jigs can be used for table saws and band saws alike, though with a table saw the backstop is tall enough that you simply run the entire thing over the blade with each pass, and with the band saw, you do NOT run the backstop through the blade, instead stopping the cut and backing straight out.


With any type of saw, you will want to tune the blade as well ... for a table saw, the blade head must be perfectly perpendicular to your miter slots.

With a band saw, you want the leading edge of the blade to be right on the crown of the wheels, so that it has the least possible deflection, and will therefore tend to cut a straighter line without veering to one side or the other.

With a miter saw, you want the blade set up to be perfectly perpendicular to the fence.


The last thing I would like to mention is .... ease of fabrication.

It would be very difficult and time-consuming to CREATE a bandsaw. I've seen plans for one made out of wood .... someday, I would love to build that thing and call it my own. For now, though, buying one would be the better idea.

On the other hand .... I can easily see how taking a circular saw and converting an existing table top or bench top into a table saw is more than doable ... I simply have to mount the saw accurately under the table to be perfectly lined up so that my clamping fence will be perpendicular to it ... cut a few miter slots into the surface, and it should be good to go. I may not have the depth of cut right away that I would like, but after it's set up I can grab a router and cut the slot for a surface plate and cut out where the saw will sit under the table and she'll be ready to rock.

I already bought the circular saw .... it was 35 dollars at harbor freight tools. If I leave off the table legs and just use the top, I can just take it down and stand it up by the wall in the corner out of the way ... or better yet, just take some strong hinges and MOUNT THE TABLE TO THE WALL with fold-out drop down legs on the front, and just fold it up out of the way when it's not in use. I can mount my router on the same table if I want.
 

Kiwiturner

Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
18
Thanks for the replies guys .. much appreciated . The bandsaw it is then. Now to sneak it into the shop without the financial administrator noticing :)
 
Top Bottom