On Cocobolo I have been successful with a regimen of cleaning with denatured alcohol, 4 think coats of thin CA, 8 thin coats of medium CA, Micromesh wet, optionally buff with blue compound on a sewn cotton wheel followed by a polish with a loosely sewn flannel wheel. I also occasionally use Doctor's Woodshop finishes, Walnut Oil sanding lube and Pens Plus finish. - Dave
PS Although more natural oil/wax "woodlike" finishes are nice, I like shiny pens - It's just a personal preference. Here are a few thumbnails of Cocobolo pens I have made with CA finishes.
View attachment 346020View attachment 346019View attachment 346017View attachment 346018
View attachment 346022