I started with that method as well, mostly because I too went by Barry's book. They looked nice and was very quick, however I found that they wore off after a while and the pens took on a patina. (gummy with oils from our hands) so I switched and took the dive into CA.
I use CA now on practically all my pens, however I still use EEE & Behlans on key chains and other small turnings that do not get handled as much. The shine lasts on those longer...at least for me.