From observing people here for a while, until their technique is perfected with experience, 5 drops on a paper towel seems to be too little for most people. The most common theme along these lines is "Why is the CA dull in one spot?" While the answer can be several items, the most common is that too little of CA is applied and it is sanded through. That happens because it is assumed that all of the CA makes it to the wood, - which you know that it doesn't.
Experiment with more and see if that helps. I was unable to buy CA in quantities more than 1 oz over here for a while and I started using rubber gloves and applying directly for a faster and more efficient use. Then 2 years ago, I found that Monty could ship it overseas and I started using paper towel again some of the time! :biggrin: