I think I get a glass like finish on AA and other poly resins, I don't use polish. After MicroMesh I buff with tripoli and a fine grain white compound (White Diamond will do) and then it shines, nothing more is needed. If you have to put a polish on it to make it shine, the shine will wear off when the polish wears off. If you get it shining without polish, it will continue to shine for the life of the pen.
Polyurethane is a different matter, it does not shine as well, the only way I can get a glass shine is with a polish, so I don't often use it.