What is high end

Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

jttheclockman

Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Messages
19,082
Location
NJ, USA.
I am curious if there are those that call slimlines highend kits then what do they call the Majestics and the $40 and $45 kits. Probably "outrageous" We have to come up with a name for them:biggrin:
 

Russianwolf

Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
5,690
Location
Martinsburg, WV, USA.
I am curious if there are those that call slimlines highend kits then what do they call the Majestics and the $40 and $45 kits. Probably "outrageous" We have to come up with a name for them:biggrin:

There's the root of another problem.

You can have high-end ballpoints that cost more than low-end fountains. There is a low-end and high-end in each kit available (usually based on plating/quality). Then there are the low-end group of kits (ballpoints) and the high-end group of kits (fountains/rollerballs).

Generally, I would call the High-end of low-end kits the better platings (Ti, platinum and chrome) of ballpoints, while the low-end of high-end kits would be the 24k gold fountains for example.

That's why I used the Cigar in my original post. It's not usually considered a high-end kit for the most part, but can be one of the high-end ballpoints depending on platings.

I like to think that I only offer high-end kit pens. I only make the two-tone cigar, Aero/EB, and long click now in Ballpoint and only use the better platings in my RB/Fountains and they are usually the Jr. series which have had good quality.
 

Smitty37

Passed Away Mar 29, 2018
In Memoriam
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
12,823
Location
Milford, Delaware 19963
fine

Smitty,

I've yet to answer any of your posts, due to the backlash each poster recieves. I'll give this a go. I think this post has alot of useful information if you would read it and put all the posts together with what your being told.

Problem with this post is there needs to be more clarification. For example ( I am using each person as an example ) I am no way trying to point out certain individuals.

What I consider high end is 15.00 due to that is the price which I can afford to put money in until it sells or I give away. Now others like Roy (Oklahoman) or Ed (Ed4copies) their price may be 25.00, they can buy in bulk which lowers the price more. The difference being the position we are in. I still consider myself fairly new and consider it a hobby while others do it for business. There is too broad of a spectrum for answers to your question. While you are looking for a simple answer...... the simple answer is the price of a high end kit is what YOU think it is. Each and every individual will have different answers.

If you read the original question I was asking what each and every individual considered it to be....nothing more.

I don't know how to make that any clearer than it is in the original post.

This was not a test. There is no right price and there is no wrong price.

If for you the answer is $15.00 than that is your answer. If for someone else is is $50 then that is his/her answer

I did not ask anyone to justify or explaiin their answer. Just what price kit they considered high end. If they use chriteria other than price to make that determination they could say that. Several folks did and that is perfectly ok it still answers the question.

I certailnly wasn't asking for a debate on the relative merits of manufacturers or the relative quality of different platings and while that might be useful information it has been and will be frequently discussed in these forums.

If pointing out to someone that they did not address the question I started the forum by asking is lashing out then I'm guilty.
 

DurocShark

Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2008
Messages
3,622
Location
Anaheim, CA
I don't know what I would consider "high-end". A $19 El Grande can be high end to me.

When I sell a pen, I classify "premium pens" as rollerball or fountain pen. Everything else is a ballpoint.

So no, I don't think price has anything to do with it for me.
 

bloodhound

Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2014
Messages
191
Location
Acushnet , ma
Hello all.

I have read all of this and dont want to start up a brawl. I asked in another post about what everyone was calling high end. It seems that was a bad question. So i guess what my problem is when i sell a pen to someone. I feel good about the finish on the turned portion. But i worry about the finish of the pen kit. I have one i bought from woodcraft. it was a copper finish. i use it daily and the finish has warn off. I cant have that.

So, Who Do You Guys/Girls Suggest I Get My Kits From?

I have been getting them from PSI. No issues that i am aware of to date. but all have been 7mm kits. And its time to step it up a bit.
 

maxwell_smart007

Lead Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
6,705
Location
middle of nowhere in the great, white North
Hello all.

I have read all of this and dont want to start up a brawl. I asked in another post about what everyone was calling high end. It seems that was a bad question. So i guess what my problem is when i sell a pen to someone. I feel good about the finish on the turned portion. But i worry about the finish of the pen kit. I have one i bought from woodcraft. it was a copper finish. i use it daily and the finish has warn off. I cant have that.

So, Who Do You Guys/Girls Suggest I Get My Kits From?

I have been getting them from PSI. No issues that i am aware of to date. but all have been 7mm kits. And its time to step it up a bit.

This thread is over four years old...
 

skiprat

Passed Away Mar 22, 2022
In Memoriam
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
7,812
Location
In a Skip in Wales
So what if this thread is over 4 years old??? It is obvious that Bloodhound used the search function to find the topic. If he asked the question in a new thread then he would likely have been told to use the search function. Jeesh, give the new guy a break......
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,069
Location
Foothill Ranch, CA
As many have said, there are so many variables and opinions out there...

I think it would be safe to say that a Jr. Gent II / Statesman would be considered 'high end' and with either the rhodium / titanium finish, would be a pen that would last a very long time. I order from Exotic Blanks or from Craft Supplies. The pen components run between $15 (for the Jr. Gent II) to $35 for the high end Jr. Statesman.

Robert
 

Fish30114

Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
484
Location
Burbs of Atlanta,Georgia
I think a true high end pen kit will be north of $30. I honestly can't find any pen kits that I feel are of high enough quality to justify prices like--let's say Cross pens get--which are mfg in China BTW, so I know it's possible that
'they' can produce a Cross caliber mechanism, we just aren't being shown or offered that to my knowledge. I suppose if a real quality mfg offered a diverse line of pens--like Lazerlines may be able to do, they would sell all the brought to market pretty quickly. I suppose also that a Cross caliber mechanism/kit would be priced around $20-$30....

Just my .02
 

bloodhound

Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2014
Messages
191
Location
Acushnet , ma
Ok. Thanks for the info everyone. I don't want to beat a 4 year old dead horse. So I will take this info and move on. There are plenty of things in this site. I'm sure I can go kick another tomb stone somewhere else. Thanks again for your time.

And thanks skiprat.
 
Last edited:

Smitty37

Passed Away Mar 29, 2018
In Memoriam
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
12,823
Location
Milford, Delaware 19963
This is a good thread for you to read....Learn something from it. There are a lot of different opinions here and also. The answers you get will often not be to the question you ask. I have said in the past "Ask an IAP member what time it is and you likely to be instructed on how to build a wrist watch"
 

bloodhound

Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2014
Messages
191
Location
Acushnet , ma
Lol I am catching on to that. Thanks smitty there is a LOT of stuff in the site. Which may be part of the problem. Most threads I will be in will be old. So if I ask a question then I am restarting a dead thread Which seems to be a no no. So I will keep the question asking to a minimum. :)
 

wwneko

Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2014
Messages
215
Location
APO, AP
Restart dead threads if it brings up a question that doesn't have the answer, other's may be interested in the topic. There are a lot of us that haven't been here for 4 years, so we may have missed a real gem. The forum is meant for learning and sharing the craft, ask away, please.
 

Cmiles1985

Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2013
Messages
1,611
Location
Aransas Pass, TX
As I sit here not feeling so well, and with a light fever, I have found this to be an excellent read.

In answer to the OP, I'd consider high end to have a sliding scale dependent on the type of pen. I consider a high end ballpoint kit to be >$12. For a RB or FP, I'd say >$20. I find my logic to be a little screwed up as I'm thinking that a ballpoint should be higher due to the mechanical piece, but that's just a random thought.
 

NittanyLion

Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
804
Location
State College PA
I do not think you can necessarily equate price with high end. Take all the new pens from PSI as an example. All priced over $20, yet many have fit/finish issues, and none of them with what many consider to be a high quality plating. To me, they are just over embellished glamour kits. I would never consider them to be a high end pen....yet PSI has done a great job marketing them. PSI found a niche in the market and a price point where they can likely make a good profit.

Personally, I consider a Rhodium Jr. Gent with a great blank and custom finial about as high end as you can get from a kit pen. It also must have great fit/finish.

Just my opinion, please do not crucify......
 

Dan Masshardt

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
4,806
Location
Mechanicsburg, PA
I don't make many pens that I'd consider to be 'high end'. Quality of blank material and craftsmanship and finish are always factors.

These are the 'kits' that I'd generally consider these to be at or toward the high end.

Emperor
Lotus
Imperial
Majestic
Statesman.
Cambridge
Sceptre

The stainless kits and jr gent 2 in better platings are in that direction but can go either way I think depending on what you do with them.
 

GaryMGg

Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
5,776
Location
McIntosh, Florida, USA.
I see a lot of discussion about "high-end" component sets. Tell me, just what price level is high end? Do you all think in the same terms when you say high end....I'm asking about kit prices not finished product.

Funny how a thread like this is pretty timeless.
Smitty, I think IF you wanted a reply based exclusively on kit cost, you should have stuck with that and omitted "Do you all think in the same terms when you say high end" because that language opens the door for all manner of opinion and you can't herd cats.
Anyway, for me the high-end cost kits were Imperial, Statesman, and Emperors in better platings. They were $50-ish and up each BUT could be had for a fair discount during group buys.
That reminds me, I've got a box full of NOS high-end kits in a drawer which need building -- I think I'll sell them to get kits for ServicePens.
 
Joined
Jan 25, 2011
Messages
819
Location
Philla., Pa.
I do not think you can necessarily equate price with high end. Take all the new pens from PSI as an example. All priced over $20, yet many have fit/finish issues, and none of them with what many consider to be a high quality plating. To me, they are just over embellished glamour kits. I would never consider them to be a high end pen....yet PSI has done a great job marketing them. PSI found a niche in the market and a price point where they can likely make a good profit.

Personally, I consider a Rhodium Jr. Gent with a great blank and custom finial about as high end as you can get from a kit pen. It also must have great fit/finish.

Just my opinion, please do not crucify......

You beat me to it. PSI has so many expensive component sets that are just ornate, blingy, or gimmicky, but not at all high end, that a price point just doesn't do it anymore.
 

Freethinker

Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
275
Location
MO.
LOL. I can commiserate with you Smitty.

You asked a simple question, yet people wanted for some reason to give answers to entirely different questions.

As a direct answer to your asking what individuals here think of as being *high end* in terms of dollars and cents....I consider anything above $25 or so to be a *high end* kit.

As someone else said, the question of how good or bad a writing instrument is created FROM a particular *high end* kit is another question entirely.

I have seen some modified slims that were very well crafted and slick looking, while I have seen some of the most expensive kits (like the Emperor or Lotus) that were a bit bulbous looking and dressed in some quite unattractive plastic blanks.
 

Smitty37

Passed Away Mar 29, 2018
In Memoriam
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
12,823
Location
Milford, Delaware 19963
I see a lot of discussion about "high-end" component sets. Tell me, just what price level is high end? Do you all think in the same terms when you say high end....I'm asking about kit prices not finished product.

Funny how a thread like this is pretty timeless.
Smitty, I think IF you wanted a reply based exclusively on kit cost, you should have stuck with that and omitted "Do you all think in the same terms when you say high end" because that language opens the door for all manner of opinion and you can't herd cats.
Anyway, for me the high-end cost kits were Imperial, Statesman, and Emperors in better platings. They were $50-ish and up each BUT could be had for a fair discount during group buys.
That reminds me, I've got a box full of NOS high-end kits in a drawer which need building -- I think I'll sell them to get kits for ServicePens.
But that sentence is pretty clear ... I think.
 

Smitty37

Passed Away Mar 29, 2018
In Memoriam
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
12,823
Location
Milford, Delaware 19963
LOL. I can commiserate with you Smitty.

You asked a simple question, yet people wanted for some reason to give answers to entirely different questions.

As a direct answer to your asking what individuals here think of as being *high end* in terms of dollars and cents....I consider anything above $25 or so to be a *high end* kit.

As someone else said, the question of how good or bad a writing instrument is created FROM a particular *high end* kit is another question entirely.

I have seen some modified slims that were very well crafted and slick looking, while I have seen some of the most expensive kits (like the Emperor or Lotus) that were a bit bulbous looking and dressed in some quite unattractive plastic blanks.
That is why I didn't ask about finished pens. We have here some pretty darned good blank makers selling blanks that cost quite a bit....I was wondering at what price level people might start using some of those blanks.....If one has a $50 or $60 blank are they going to put it on a $10 kit was something I was thinking there.
 

Smitty37

Passed Away Mar 29, 2018
In Memoriam
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
12,823
Location
Milford, Delaware 19963
I do not think you can necessarily equate price with high end. Take all the new pens from PSI as an example. All priced over $20, yet many have fit/finish issues, and none of them with what many consider to be a high quality plating. To me, they are just over embellished glamour kits. I would never consider them to be a high end pen....yet PSI has done a great job marketing them. PSI found a niche in the market and a price point where they can likely make a good profit.

Personally, I consider a Rhodium Jr. Gent with a great blank and custom finial about as high end as you can get from a kit pen. It also must have great fit/finish.

Just my opinion, please do not crucify......

You beat me to it. PSI has so many expensive component sets that are just ornate, blingy, or gimmicky, but not at all high end, that a price point just doesn't do it anymore.
They didn't have them when the question was asked...I might word the question differently today. BTW many of those PSI kits are the same kits with different cap/clip/tip. They have found a cheap way to introduce different designs for one, two or all of them.
 

lwalper

Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2014
Messages
492
Location
Lancaster, TN
I am loathe to pay more than $5-6 for a kit. Most of them don't cost that much to produce. I know the distributors are filling a demand and I don't have a problem with some enterprising individual making a living, covering their costs, and making a business work. That said, a good quality mechanism (one that works well and reliably) coupled with a skilled artist/turner creates a "quality" pen. Quality components would include the components which actually involve more $$ materials, machining and better quality control on the front end.

The slimline/trimline style kits are affordable and can be turned into a "quality" product. For just a couple of bucks investment you can produce a really nice pen. If you find demand for "high-end" there's always the sterling silver or stainless steel available. For what they are even those parts seem to be reasonably priced, but you'll need a market that will appreciate the initial outlay to justify the price of a pen starting out with "quality" components.
 
Top Bottom