I'ld have used Bethlehem Olivewood, as it would have a bit more of a sentimental meaning for a pastor, but if you used the silmar so that it would stand out a bit less (more of an understatement rather than attention grabbing) then that would make a bit of sense too...
The fit and finish look great!
Nice work - thanks for remembering and honoring your pastor. Even with October being Pastor Appreciation month, many pastors receive very little tangible signs of appreciation.